Hall of Fame voter reconsiders ex-MLB star's candidacy: "I didn't get credit for what I did"

The 2025 National Baseball Hall of Fame inductees are CC Sabathia, Ichiro Suzuki, and Billy Wagner, who will be honored in Cooperstown with the game's legends.

Despite the baseball world's celebration of these three exceptional ballplayers, there are others who have compelling cases for the Hall of Fame but have yet to receive a chance to enter.

Kenny Lofton, a six-time All-Star and four-time Gold Glover, played 17 seasons in MLB and accumulated 2,428 hits and a 68.4 WAR over 2,103 games.

When the Hall of Fame ballots are counted and the results are announced on Tuesday, Lofton won't be upset. He understands that since he didn't receive at least 5% of the vote in 2013, he is no longer eligible for regular voting.

Lofton is still hurt that he didn't receive a fair chance to be inducted into Cooperstown.

Lofton told Planet Chronicle Digital that he didn't receive credit for his contributions to Sluggball, a reimagined version of baseball, which he finds disappointing. Despite this, he continues to work as an advisor with the game.

"From my perspective, I always believed it was crucial to fulfill my responsibilities as a teammate during my era. At the time, I thought it was essential to contribute to the game as a team player. However, now that I look back, I realize that my actions may have been perceived as selfish, as compared to other players who were more focused on their individual performance. While I was providing the food for them, they were consuming it, and I didn't receive the recognition for my efforts. In hindsight, I realize that I should have been more selfless and focused on the team's success rather than my own individual accomplishments."

Lofton's first year on the Hall of Fame ballot was one of the most competitive, with 10 players vying for the 75% of votes needed to get in. However, Lofton and Bernie Williams were not among the lucky ones and were left off the ballot the next year, as at least 5% of votes is required to move on.

The Steroid Era, which was the era in which the player played, included Barry Bonds (36.2%), Mark McGwire (16.9%), Sammy Sosa (12.5%), and Rafael Palmeiro (8.8%) on the ballot with him.

Ichiro, who entered MLB at the age of 27 in 2001, accumulated 3,089 hits over 19 seasons. Despite being a strong candidate for a unanimous Hall of Fame vote, only one voter left him off their ballot.

Ichiro and Tim Raines both received their due recognition, but Lofton believes he should be included in the same conversation.

Seeing Ichiro with the opportunity to showcase smaller guys who are not all about home runs can get in the game, and then comparing my numbers to Ichiro, we're not too far off, hurts me to see this, Lofton explained.

The Hall of Fame is often determined by Wins Above Replacement (WAR), which Ichiro had at 60.0 and Lofton at 68.4.

When comparing their career season averages, Lofton excelled in stolen bases (48 to 31), home runs (10 to 7), RBI (60 to 48), and runs (118 to 87). However, Ichiro outperformed Lofton in batting average (.311 to .299), but only by two in hits (189 to 187).

The JAWS metric, created by sabermetrician Jay Jaffe in "The Cooperstown Casebook," determines Hall of Fame eligibility by averaging a player's WAR with their 7-year peak WAR.

Mike Trout and Carlos Beltran are the only center fielders ahead of Lofton in the all-time JAWS rankings, and Trout is still an active player while Beltran remains on the ballot.

The Hall of Fame includes players with lower JAWS ratings, such as Richie Ashburn, Andrew Dawson, Billy Hamilton, Larry Doby, Earl Averill, Max Carey, and Kirby Puckett.

Lofton's talent for stealing bases, with a career total of 622 stolen bags, made him a threat when he got on base. Despite being one of only nine players with both 600 career steals and extra-base hits, Lofton is not enshrined in the Hall of Fame.

"Lofton requested that people pay more attention to his statistics, stating that he has one of the highest WARs in history for center fielders."

Lofton shared with me that his peers fondly remembered their time in the league while reminiscing.

Barry Larkin, a Hall of Famer, told me that during my playing days, I was the best thing out there. He said that no one wanted to deal with me when I was at the plate or in the outfield. Hearing that from another player made me feel good.

"During the World Series, David Justice stated, "Our main goal was to keep Kenny Lofton off the bases." He added, "We didn't have a big meeting. We had a meeting that said, 'Keep that damn Kenny Lofton off the bases and we will win this series.' Hearing that kind of stuff from the players I played with made me feel good.""

In December 2025, the Contemporary Committee will vote on whether to allow Lofton into the Hall. However, the ballot will only have eight candidates, and 75% of the votes must be in favor for Lofton to be admitted.

In 2022, Lofton had already gone through that when Fred McGriff was elected by the committee. McGriff finished his 19-year career with 493 homers and a 52.6 WAR.

Lofton isn't criticizing these players for receiving their Hall of Fame plaque; instead, he is requesting the recognition he believes he deserves.

He now doubts the value of his efforts.

Sometimes, I question whether I played the game correctly, like, 'Dude, did I do it the right way?'" Lofton mused. "It seems like people are receiving recognition for their current actions, while I feel like my past contributions were overlooked. I used to believe that being a leadoff hitter was important because he helped the team. RBI stands for run batted in, so all these big guys are getting praised for their runs batted in. However, how can they receive credit for their runs batted in if they didn't get on base first? It's disheartening.

"I simply want the committee to evaluate my performance and declare me the best at it. However, I am uncertain if they will do so. It is not my responsibility, but I urge them to compare my numbers with those of Hall of Fame members."

Subscribe to the Planet Chronicle Sports Huddle newsletter and follow our sports coverage on X.