CNBC hosts and Harris campaign economic adviser clash over unrealized gains tax proposal: 'Unconstitutional'

A 25% tax on unrealized capital gains for high-net-worth individuals is proposed.

CNBC hosts and Harris campaign economic adviser clash over unrealized gains tax proposal: 'Unconstitutional'
CNBC hosts and Harris campaign economic adviser clash over unrealized gains tax proposal: 'Unconstitutional'

The hosts of CNBC's "Squawk Box" disagreed with Bharat Ramamurti, an informal economic adviser on Vice President Kamala Harris' campaign, about the fairness and constitutionality of the Biden-Harris proposal to tax unrealized capital gains.

Rebecca Quick and Joe Kernen questioned Rama about the proposal, which Rebecca deemed unreasonable because it would advance taxes that would be paid later when someone sells the stock.

According to reports from The Wall Street Journal and The New York Times, Harris supports the tax increases proposed by Biden in his recent budget plan, including a 25% tax on unrealized capital gains for individuals with more than $100 million in wealth and an increased corporate tax rate from 21% to 28%.

Ramamurti found it amusing that the reaction to unrealized gains was a little off, considering that most people watching were already paying taxes on such gains. He explained that this was known as a property tax.

Joe Kernen and Bharat Ramamurti
CNBC's Joe Kernen and Rebecca Quick pressed Bharat Ramamurti on Harris' economic proposals on Wednesday.  (Screenshot/CNBC)

Property taxes are used for schools, so Quick and Kernen quickly disagreed.

Even if they decide not to sell their home, individuals still pay higher taxes when the value of their property increases, according to Ramamurti.

Your home's value doesn't fluctuate like a stock, and it's not something you can sell. Additionally, property tax is a use tax, which funds things like schools and emergency services, making perfect sense.

Harris' plan, as well as the revenue generated from unrealized gains tax, would offer more chances for Americans, as Ramamurti emphasized.

Harris and Walz at DNC
Democratic presidential nominee, U.S. Vice President Kamala Harris and Democratic vice presidential nominee Minnesota Gov. Tim Walz celebrate during the final day of the Democratic National Convention at the United Center on August 22, 2024 in Chicago, Illinois.  ( Justin Sullivan/Getty Images)

Quick stated that it is not a tax for those who are utilizing the services.

Kernen remarked, "It's probably unconstitutional," before joking that it unlikely would occur in Quick's lifetime.

The projected revenue from the unrealized gains tax and substantial capital gains tax increase is estimated to be nearly $800 billion, according to a Peter G. Peterson Foundation analysis.

Planet Chronicle' Kristen Altus contributed to this report.

by Hanna Panreck

media

Chicago schools allegedly directed teachers to assign passing grades to migrants regardless of their academic performance.

Chicago schools allegedly directed teachers to assign passing grades to migrants regardless of their academic performance.

media
Nearly 60% of Teamsters members back Trump, surprising many: "Nobody ever expected" this to occur.

Nearly 60% of Teamsters members back Trump, surprising many: "Nobody ever expected" this to occur.

media
Trump receives endorsement from Lady Gaga's father in 2024 presidential race.

Trump receives endorsement from Lady Gaga's father in 2024 presidential race.

media
Some Hispanic voters in Nevada are considering voting for Trump due to the current economic conditions.

Some Hispanic voters in Nevada are considering voting for Trump due to the current economic conditions.

media
Trump claims that Howard Stern was excellent until he became "woke," and ratings have plummeted as a result.

Trump claims that Howard Stern was excellent until he became "woke," and ratings have plummeted as a result.

media
MSNBC reports that Putin will be impressed by the US electing a Black woman, a "product of mixed marriage."

MSNBC reports that Putin will be impressed by the US electing a Black woman, a "product of mixed marriage."

media
A 20-year-old nursing home worker who attempted to assassinate President Trump is revealed by Jesse Watters.

A 20-year-old nursing home worker who attempted to assassinate President Trump is revealed by Jesse Watters.

media
Kamala Harris defies the stereotype of a typical Democrat.

Kamala Harris defies the stereotype of a typical Democrat.

media
The Biden-Harris administration remains silent on certain issues.

The Biden-Harris administration remains silent on certain issues.

media
Report: Nearly all coverage of Trump on ABC, CBS, NBC after 2nd assassination attempt is negative.

Report: Nearly all coverage of Trump on ABC, CBS, NBC after 2nd assassination attempt is negative.

media
Trump admits he regrets not confronting ABC moderators during the debate: "I wish I had"

Trump admits he regrets not confronting ABC moderators during the debate: "I wish I had"

media
CNN's Bash suggests that you could play a drinking game for every time Harris repeats the same talking points.

CNN's Bash suggests that you could play a drinking game for every time Harris repeats the same talking points.

media
A Washington D.C. city council member proposes businesses adopt a cashless policy to reduce crime.

A Washington D.C. city council member proposes businesses adopt a cashless policy to reduce crime.

media
CNN host Abby Phillip criticized Kamala Harris' interview with Black journalists for lacking specifics.

CNN host Abby Phillip criticized Kamala Harris' interview with Black journalists for lacking specifics.

media
Seinfeld' actor claims new Watergate documentary exonerates Nixon: 'He was railroaded

Seinfeld' actor claims new Watergate documentary exonerates Nixon: 'He was railroaded

media
''The View' host defends Brittany Mahomes for supporting Trump: "She's in an interracial marriage"'

''The View' host defends Brittany Mahomes for supporting Trump: "She's in an interracial marriage"'

media