'The director of "Conclave" clarifies that the film's depiction of controversial scenes during papal elections is not a criticism of the church.'

The novel 'Conclave' by Robert Harris served as the inspiration for the term 'conclave'.

'The director of "Conclave" clarifies that the film's depiction of controversial scenes during papal elections is not a criticism of the church.'
'The director of "Conclave" clarifies that the film's depiction of controversial scenes during papal elections is not a criticism of the church.'

Edward Berger's new film about the papal election process may surprise and shock traditional Catholics.

The film "Conclave," starring Ralph Fiennes, Stanley Tucci, John Lithgow, and Lucian Msamati, is a captivating portrayal of the process of selecting a new pope, as depicted in Robert Harris' 2016 novel of the same name. Isabella Rosellini delivers a standout performance as Sister Agnes, who watches the cardinals' schemes unfold from the sidelines.

Director Edward Berger stated to Planet Chronicle Digital that in the beginning of the film, Stanley Tucci references a chess game, and he felt that the movie is like a well-constructed architectural chess game where people are competing for the top job - the throne is vacant and people are getting out their daggers to conquer that throne.

"The situation is highly competitive, intriguing, and suspenseful. Additionally, the interior journey of Ralph Fiennes's character is engaging and full of struggle and doubt. The script is complex and keeps surprising the audience with many twists and surprises."

A photo of Vatican City
(Riccardo De Luca/Anadolu via Getty Images)

Berger frequently consulted religious advisors, such as Francesco Bonomo, for guidance on filming, including filling in the gaps on how people vote, the oaths given, the prayers said, how to hold hands and kneel, among other things.

"Berger stated to Planet Chronicle Digital, "We made every effort to ensure accuracy and, for the unknown elements, we incorporated our own reality because it's a film.""

"We conducted numerous location scouts in Rome and filmed there, which impacted our daily shoots. Looking out the window, I observed priests and nuns heading to work, and I thought, 'They're simply humans carrying out their daily routines.'"

The film frequently depicts cardinals as relatable individuals through their use of phones, vaping, and emotional breakdowns while competing for the papacy following the demise of the previous pope.

"Berger stated that the Vatican is portrayed as human in their representation. They showcase humans with issues, doubts, questions, insecurities, vices, and past sins as they strive to overcome them. In terms of research, they consulted with cardinals beforehand for guidance, but ultimately, the conclave doors close, and no one can disclose what transpires within."

The movie's ending may be a shock for those who haven't read Harris' "Conclave." Some Catholic bloggers have criticized the book as "anti-Catholic" or used the term "woke" when they discovered how the papal election ultimately plays out and takes a progressive turn. Berger stated that the film was not intended to offend the church when asked how traditional Catholics would react to the feature film.

"Berger stated to Planet Chronicle Digital that we live in a world that has neglected the art of discussing and disagreeing, and engaging in a proper discourse. He further explained that he is receptive to other people's arguments and tries to understand their feelings and thoughts. He believes in learning from others and revising his own ideas to improve his attitude and education."

"He clarified that the film was not a criticism of the church, but rather a portrayal of people as human and equal. Many Catholics and cardinals he had spoken to in Europe were excited to see the movie and planned to watch it without judgment."

Pope Francis East Timor
Pope Francis attends a mass at the Esplanade of Tasitolu in Dili, East Timor, on September 10, 2024. (Tiziana FABI / AFP) (Photo by TIZIANA FABI/AFP via Getty Images))

The film portrays several cardinals, including Italian Cardinal Tedesco, as "villains." In one scene, he expresses his concern about the growing number of Muslims in Europe and the Church's perceived tolerance of other religions.

Some priests are cautioning Catholics against watching the film.

Fr. Jonathan Meyer of All Saints Parish in Guilford, Indiana, stated in a YouTube video message that this film "discredits the Holy Roman Catholic Church" by "eroding salvation" and "mocking salvation." Some commenters described the movie as a "mockery" of the Church.

The movie has received a 93 percent rating on Rotten Tomatoes and is being considered for Oscar contention due to its suspense and strong performances.

The novel "Conclave" explores the question of how men behave when given power, as portrayed through the characters' ruthless power struggles. Unfortunately, the portrayal is not positive.

"Berger stated to Planet Chronicle Digital that the decision to fill the vacant position is of utmost importance. The position is incredibly powerful, possibly the most powerful in the world, and its absence will create a power vacuum. This vacuum will motivate some individuals to pursue the position, regardless of their moral character. Ambition can bring out both positive and negative aspects in people, and it is essential to portray the situation as a human drama that mirrors any other vacant position globally."

The movie depicts the process of selecting the next pope, which is indicated by white smoke from the Sistine Chapel chimney.

The timing of the film's release coincided with the approaching U.S. presidential election, making it difficult to ignore the connection.

Maryland Board of Elections poll workers pass by empty booths during the Maryland state primary election
Maryland Board of Elections poll workers pass by empty booths during the Maryland state primary election at a polling station in Annapolis, Maryland, on May 14, 2024. (Photo by Jim WATSON / AFP) (Photo by JIM WATSON/AFP via Getty Images)

"Berger stated that when making a movie, one always aims to reflect the current time and incorporate current events into the film, resulting in a political drama."

"For eight years, we have been working on this film, and there was never any intention of releasing it this year. However, it just so happened to be the truth. The reality of our current situation is reflected in the film, making it relevant and interesting. Regardless of where the film takes place, whether it's the Vatican, Washington, D.C., or a boardroom, it showcases a universal truth that occurs everywhere: when a position is vacant and needs to be filled, different political agendas or agendas that conflict with each other emerge."

Berger, who was raised Protestant, expressed interest in various faiths and their rituals, particularly the Catholic Church, due to its "mystery, mystique, drama, theatricality, and lends itself to a film."

Should the Catholic Church evolve?

"Berger stated to Planet Chronicle Digital that the absence of tradition, identity, history, and culture would make it a crucial aspect of our cultures. Additionally, he believes that it is essential to embrace modernity and be open to different aspects of it, such as a feminine presence, without any harm to the organization."

"Conclave" is in theaters now.

by Cortney O'Brien

media

Tom Homan, border czar, sends message to far-left officials: "Game on"

Tom Homan, border czar, sends message to far-left officials: "Game on"

media
The Washington Post claims that both Biden and Trump have disregarded the rule of law.

The Washington Post claims that both Biden and Trump have disregarded the rule of law.

media
President Trump's criticisms of the Reverend were "respectful," according to the Reverend herself.

President Trump's criticisms of the Reverend were "respectful," according to the Reverend herself.

media
Columbia University professor discusses how protesters took control of class and distributed antisemitic literature.

Columbia University professor discusses how protesters took control of class and distributed antisemitic literature.

media
Hollywood's unease with Kamala Harris' election loss: "No longer in control"

Hollywood's unease with Kamala Harris' election loss: "No longer in control"

media
TikTok debate sparks concern in Dave Portnoy about small business owners.

TikTok debate sparks concern in Dave Portnoy about small business owners.

media
Parents who lean left are grappling with sons who support Trump, according to a New York Times article.

Parents who lean left are grappling with sons who support Trump, according to a New York Times article.

media
Snoop Dogg and Nelly face criticism from 'The View' hosts for performing at Trump inauguration.

Snoop Dogg and Nelly face criticism from 'The View' hosts for performing at Trump inauguration.

media
Biden's last-second preemptive pardons criticized by 'The View' co-host, legacy tarnished.

Biden's last-second preemptive pardons criticized by 'The View' co-host, legacy tarnished.

media
Trump's deportation plan is condemned as a 'disgrace' by Pope Francis.

Trump's deportation plan is condemned as a 'disgrace' by Pope Francis.

media
Biden's former communications director criticizes ex-president's last-minute pardons as a "disappointing move."

Biden's former communications director criticizes ex-president's last-minute pardons as a "disappointing move."

media
A high-stakes defamation trial is set to begin in the 'uterus collector' lawsuit against MSNBC.

A high-stakes defamation trial is set to begin in the 'uterus collector' lawsuit against MSNBC.

media
Jason Aldean discusses his thoughts on the inauguration and observes a change in celebrities' views on Trump.

Jason Aldean discusses his thoughts on the inauguration and observes a change in celebrities' views on Trump.

media