A CNN legal analyst claims that Special Counsel Jack Smith broke rules to secure a "cheap shot" against Trump prior to the election.

Smith's legal practice was deemed "unprincipled" and "norm-breaking" by CNN's senior legal analyst.

A CNN legal analyst claims that Special Counsel Jack Smith broke rules to secure a "cheap shot" against Trump prior to the election.
A CNN legal analyst claims that Special Counsel Jack Smith broke rules to secure a "cheap shot" against Trump prior to the election.

A legal analyst argued in a New York Magazine piece that special counsel Jack Smith "deviated from standard practice" by targeting former President Trump after the election, rather than trying the candidate beforehand.

In Elie Honig's "Jack Smith's October Cheap Shot" essay on CNN, the senior legal analyst analyzed the decision made by Jack Smith to drop a 165-page federal court filing concerning the issue of Trump's immunity from prosecution.

Judge Tanya Chutkan granted Smith permission to file a 180-page long brief, which is four times the normal maximum, according to Honig.

Despite earlier efforts to expedite Trump's immunity and get it in before November 5, Chutkan now claims she does not care about the upcoming election. After redacting several names, she complied with Smith's request and made the rest of the brief public.

Jack smith
Special Counsel Jack Smith delivers remarks on a recently unsealed indictment including four felony counts against former U.S. President Donald Trump at the Justice Department on August 1, 2023 in Washington, DC. (Alex Wong/Getty Images)

Smith has abandoned any pretense and is willing to bend any rule or switch up on any practice as long as it helps him harm Trump's electoral prospects. There is no defending Smith's conduct on any principled or institutional basis.

Smith's "unprincipled, norm-breaking practice" does not justify suggestions that voters should have the utmost information about presidential candidates before casting their ballot.

According to Honig, Smith violated standard criminal procedure and federal rules by asking Chutkan to file an indictment without a pending defense motion.

Honig continued, "Smith's request to file first was 'procedurally irregular,' and Trump's team objected. The judge acknowledged this before ruling in Smith's favor, as she has done at virtually every consequential turn."

donald trump rally
Former President Donald Trump speaks at the U.S.-Mexico border on August 22, 2024 south of Sierra Vista, Arizona. (Rebecca Noble)

Smith's proactive filing is "prejudicial" to Trump in the legal and political sense, but also ironic because Smith previously complained that Trump's words might taint the jury pool for the case.

Smith has disclosed a substantial document with potentially damaging statements about a criminal defendant, which was created using grand-jury testimony that is typically kept confidential at this stage of the case and was not subjected to the rules of evidence or cross-examination.

Smith's behavior, according to Honig, goes against the fundamental principles and policies of the Department of Justice (DOJ).

If prosecutors compromise their principles based on the target's identity, they have no principles.

In the unsealed filing, Smith argued that Trump is not immune from the remaining allegations against him and presented his case for why Trump should be tried for his private crimes.

Planet Chronicle Digital reached out to the Justice Department for comment.

Trump has pleaded not guilty to all charges brought against him by Smith.

by Nikolas Lanum

media

Lawmakers from the Democratic party drafted a letter accusing Meta, OpenAI, and Google of attempting to "curry favor" with former President Trump.

Lawmakers from the Democratic party drafted a letter accusing Meta, OpenAI, and Google of attempting to "curry favor" with former President Trump.

media
TikTok influencers express disappointment and sadness after Supreme Court ruling: 'I can't believe this is happening'

TikTok influencers express disappointment and sadness after Supreme Court ruling: 'I can't believe this is happening'

media
Colbert jests that he may lose his show under Trump, lamenting the end of the Biden administration.

Colbert jests that he may lose his show under Trump, lamenting the end of the Biden administration.

media
Navy veteran wins punitive damages from CNN for defamation.

Navy veteran wins punitive damages from CNN for defamation.

media
Biden's 2024 campaign: Schumer reveals private talks with president.

Biden's 2024 campaign: Schumer reveals private talks with president.

media
In his final interview with MSNBC, Lawrence O'Donnell praises Biden's accomplishments, calling them "like a magic trick."

In his final interview with MSNBC, Lawrence O'Donnell praises Biden's accomplishments, calling them "like a magic trick."

media
Stephen A. Smith criticizes those who try to appease Trump to avoid being attacked.

Stephen A. Smith criticizes those who try to appease Trump to avoid being attacked.

media
Jake Tapper of CNN concedes that the Hur report on Biden's memory was mostly accurate in hindsight.

Jake Tapper of CNN concedes that the Hur report on Biden's memory was mostly accurate in hindsight.

media
Michelle Obama's absence from Trump's inauguration has left Kid Rock feeling a bit miffed.

Michelle Obama's absence from Trump's inauguration has left Kid Rock feeling a bit miffed.

media
Biden's Justice Department prosecuted 21 pro-life protesters, and Trump was urged to pardon them.

Biden's Justice Department prosecuted 21 pro-life protesters, and Trump was urged to pardon them.

media
Jim Acosta of CNN responds to Trump's characterization of the media as "the enemy of the people" in an interview.

Jim Acosta of CNN responds to Trump's characterization of the media as "the enemy of the people" in an interview.

media
The CNN defamation trial: Closing arguments presented as jury begins to weigh lawsuit against network.

The CNN defamation trial: Closing arguments presented as jury begins to weigh lawsuit against network.

media
Biden's departure from office leaves Joy Behar feeling nostalgic: "I'll miss him already"

Biden's departure from office leaves Joy Behar feeling nostalgic: "I'll miss him already"

media
The cease-fire deal was secured due to Trump's influence, as stated by an ABC host on 'The View'.

The cease-fire deal was secured due to Trump's influence, as stated by an ABC host on 'The View'.

media
Video captures family's harrowing evacuation from Pacific Palisades during Los Angeles wildfires.

Video captures family's harrowing evacuation from Pacific Palisades during Los Angeles wildfires.

media
Michigan Democrat declines to align with her 'disconnected party': "I'm better off on my own"

Michigan Democrat declines to align with her 'disconnected party': "I'm better off on my own"

media