A report claims that ICC prosecutor Khan co-authored an essay arguing that defendants cannot receive a fair trial at the world court.

Benjamin Netanyahu and Yoav Gallant are the latest targets of arrest warrants issued by Karim Khan.

A report claims that ICC prosecutor Khan co-authored an essay arguing that defendants cannot receive a fair trial at the world court.
A report claims that ICC prosecutor Khan co-authored an essay arguing that defendants cannot receive a fair trial at the world court.

In 2013, British chief prosecutor Karim Khan for the International Criminal Court (ICC) published an essay arguing that his attempt to arrest Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu would be a violation of justice because the court cannot provide defendants with due process.

The Middle East Media Research Institute (MEMRI), based in Washington, D.C., analyzed the key elements of an essay published by Duke University's Law School.

Yigal Carmon, the founder and president of MEMRI, stated that Khan's essay, titled "Defensive Practices: Representing Clients Before the International Criminal Court," revealed that the ICC is unable to deliver justice.

Khan, along with attorney Anand A. Shah, co-authored an essay that Carmon cited passages from. Shah is a member of the New York State Bar.

Karim Khan speaking at a microphone
Karim Khan is the ICC's chief prosecutor. (Getty Images)

Whether defendants can secure a fair trial when brought before the world court is questioned by Khan's academic paper.

The prosecutor at the ICC can use anonymous summaries of witness evidence that may lack substance or coherence in their case against the defendant.

The public perception of a client's guilt is often intensified by the support of well-funded civil-society groups, NGOs, and international media, which can create a narrative that is widely accepted as true before the client has even had a chance to appear in court.

Karim Khan
Lawyers for former Liberian President Charles Taylor, from left to right, Karim Khan, an unidentified lawyer and James L. Supuwood, attend the third status conference in the case of The Prosecutor vs. Charles Ghankay Taylor at the International Criminal Court in The Hague, Netherlands, on Jan. 26, 2007. (Photo by KOEN VAN WEEL/POOL/AFP via Getty Images)

Khan pointed out flaws in the evidentiary rules at the ICC. He stated, "The standard of proof at the confirmation stage, which is 'sufficient evidence to establish substantial grounds to believe,' is lower than the beyond-a-reasonable-doubt standard needed to secure a conviction at trial."

The ICC is located in The Hague, Netherlands.

This month, Khan requested the ICC to issue arrest warrants against Netanyahu and Israeli Defense Minister Yoav Gallant for alleged war crimes committed during Israel's campaign against Hamas in Gaza.

Israeli PM Netanyahu and Gallant
Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu, right, and Israeli Defense Minister Yoav Gallant are pictured in the West Bank in August 2023. (Amos Ben-Gershom (GPO)/Handout/Anadolu Agency via Getty Images)

In 2007, Khan was close to being held in contempt by the ICC while representing former Liberian President Charles Taylor, who was accused of committing war crimes in Sierra Leone.

The presiding judge cautioned Khan at the time that "your conduct cannot override a court order which I issued a few minutes ago," and the court instructed Khan to take a seat. The judge then invited the prosecution to proceed with its opening statement when Khan refused to participate in the legal proceedings. Khan dramatically gathered his materials and exited the courtroom, as reported in The Cambridge Companion to International Criminal Law. In 2012, the ICC convicted Taylor.

Hamas
Terrorists from Hamas are seen during an anti-Israel military march in Gaza City. (Yousef Masoud/Majority World/Universal Images Group via Getty Images)

Nearly 1,200 people were killed by Hamas during their invasion of Israel on Oct. 7, including more than 30 Americans. Over 250 people were also kidnapped by the jihadi terrorist organization. Currently, Hamas is holding 125 hostages in Gaza.

Israel's government spokeswoman, Tal Heinrich, stated to Planet Chronicle Digital that the ICC is conducting a "vicious smear" campaign against Israeli leaders. She added that Israel's government has not yet reviewed Khan's 2013 essay or the MEMRI report.

Netanyahu stated that the ICC arrest warrant is an example of the new form of antisemitism.

Hague Netherlands Headquarters
A general view of the International Criminal Court building in The Hague, Netherlands on April 30, 2024. (Selman Aksunger/Anadolu via Getty Images)

Numerous email press queries were sent to Khan and the ICC by Planet Chronicle Digital, but multiple phone calls were not returned.

Fadi El Abdallah, a spokesman for the ICC, informed Planet Chronicle Digital via WhatsApp that the prosecutor's office had not responded to their inquiry. He explained that they may be busy and thanked them for their understanding. In a second message, he stated that he could not provide any further assistance as it was within the jurisdiction of the prosecutor's team. Unfortunately, attempts to contact Khan's co-author, Shah, were unsuccessful.

by Benjamin Weinthal

world

Dozens of global arrests were made after Australian police busted the Ghost cybercrime app.

Dozens of global arrests were made after Australian police busted the Ghost cybercrime app.

world
An expert warns that a UN resolution calling for Israel to withdraw from "occupied territories" could exacerbate the already "highly volatile" situation.

An expert warns that a UN resolution calling for Israel to withdraw from "occupied territories" could exacerbate the already "highly volatile" situation.

world
Flight attendant dies after boarding ITA Airways plane in Italy.

Flight attendant dies after boarding ITA Airways plane in Italy.

world
An ancient Celtic artifact, a 2,300-year-old metal object, was discovered in Poland, extracted from a charcoal pit.

An ancient Celtic artifact, a 2,300-year-old metal object, was discovered in Poland, extracted from a charcoal pit.

world
An earthquake-sized explosion caused by a Ukrainian drone strike on Russia was detected from space.

An earthquake-sized explosion caused by a Ukrainian drone strike on Russia was detected from space.

world
Hezbollah members injured in Lebanon due to exploding pagers condemned by Russia: 'Explosive situation'

Hezbollah members injured in Lebanon due to exploding pagers condemned by Russia: 'Explosive situation'

world
An American citizen has been arrested in Venezuela on charges of participating in a plot to assassinate President Maduro.

An American citizen has been arrested in Venezuela on charges of participating in a plot to assassinate President Maduro.

world
Experts: Israel successfully degrades Iran-backed Hezbollah terrorists in a spectacular page explosion operation.

Experts: Israel successfully degrades Iran-backed Hezbollah terrorists in a spectacular page explosion operation.

world
A Taiwanese company claims that the Hezbollah pagers that exploded were manufactured in Hungary.

A Taiwanese company claims that the Hezbollah pagers that exploded were manufactured in Hungary.

world
Canadian Prime Minister Trudeau acknowledges that there is still work to be done after his party loses a long-held seat in Quebec.

Canadian Prime Minister Trudeau acknowledges that there is still work to be done after his party loses a long-held seat in Quebec.

world
Central Europe's Budapest and Wroclaw fortify riverbanks against impending floods.

Central Europe's Budapest and Wroclaw fortify riverbanks against impending floods.

world
In Mali's capital, a lethal assault occurred at a training camp involving militants.

In Mali's capital, a lethal assault occurred at a training camp involving militants.

world
Germany tightens immigration laws in response to voter backlash.

Germany tightens immigration laws in response to voter backlash.

world
Amid US and UK concerns, a top Russian official visits Iran for alleged nuclear deal talks.

Amid US and UK concerns, a top Russian official visits Iran for alleged nuclear deal talks.

world
Critics claim that France's culture of sexual assault is exposed during the mass rape trial.

Critics claim that France's culture of sexual assault is exposed during the mass rape trial.

world
Blinken journeys to Egypt for peace negotiations as Israel announces fresh war objective

Blinken journeys to Egypt for peace negotiations as Israel announces fresh war objective

world