The NC Supreme Court election battle is being sent back to the state court by a federal judge.

Despite two recounts showing Democrat Allison Riggs in a lead, Republican Jefferson Griffin is challenging 60,000 ballots.

The NC Supreme Court election battle is being sent back to the state court by a federal judge.
The NC Supreme Court election battle is being sent back to the state court by a federal judge.

On Tuesday, North Carolina's highest court blocked the certification of the election results between Democratic Associate Justice Allison Riggs and GOP challenger Jefferson Griffin, who lost the general election. Despite two recounts, one statewide machine recount and a partial hand-to-eye recount of ballots from randomly selected early voting sites and Election Day precincts in each county, the results still showed Riggs in the lead. The Democrat is now contending that 60,000 ballots cast should be invalidated, which would change the outcome of the election.

An eight-year term on the Supreme Court awaits the ultimate winner, with five of the seven current justices being registered Republicans.

Griffin's challenges to most of the ballots were based on voter registration records that lacked either a driver's license number or the last four digits of a Social Security number, which has been required in registration applications since 2004. Prior to the federal Help America Vote Act of 2002, voter registration forms did not clearly require the last four digits of a Social Security number or a driver's license number.

Despite the inability to validate a person's last four Social Security numbers or driver's license digits, it is still legal to vote. The state elections administration office will assign a special identification number to the person if they present a HAVA document, such as a utility bill.

Griffin and Riggs side by side
North Carolina Court of Appeals Judge Jefferson Griffin and North Carolina Supreme Court Associate Justice Allison Riggs.  (North Carolina Administrative Office of the Courts via AP)

Griffin is challenging votes cast by overseas voters who have never lived in the U.S. but whose parents were deemed North Carolina residents and by military or overseas voters who did not provide copies of photo identification with their ballots. According to federal law, overseas voters are exempt from providing photo identification with their ballots.

Three weeks ago, Griffin, a judge on the intermediate-level state Court of Appeals, had lawyers request intervention from the state Supreme Court.

The elections board promptly transferred the matter to federal court, stating that Griffin's appeals pertained to federal voting laws and rights.

On Monday, U.S. District Judge Richard Myers concurred with Griffin's stance and sent the case back to the state Supreme Court.

Griffin's protests, according to Myers, a Trump nominee to the bench, raised unsettled questions of state law and had tenuous connections to federal law.

Democrats protest NC judge recount
North Carolina state Democratic Party Chair Anderson Clayton, left, speaks at a news conference about the pending election for a state Supreme Court seat on Tuesday, Dec. 10, 2024, on Capitol Square in Raleigh, N.C.  (AP Photo/Gary D. Robertson)

The state Supreme Court granted a temporary stay hours later when Griffin's attorneys requested it.

"Expeditiously address this matter concerning election certification as there is no stay from federal court," Tuesday's order read.

Riggs recused herself from the matter, while Associate Justice Anita Earls, the other Democrat on the court, opposed the stay in part because the "public interest requires that the Court not interfere with the ordinary course of democratic processes as set by statute and the state constitution."

The state board and Riggs' attorneys filed appeals notices for Myers' decision with the 4th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals. The state board later requested the appeals court to direct Myers to withdraw the litigation from the state Supreme Court and prevent its return to the state court until the matter is resolved through appeal.

The Republican-majority state Supreme Court would essentially be asked to decide the winner for one of its own seats, barring intervention by federal appeals judges.

North Carolina voters in Hendersonville
Voters make selections at their voting booths inside an early voting site on Oct. 17, 2024, in Hendersonville, North Carolina, in the aftermath of Hurricane Helene. (Melissa Sue Gerrits/Getty Images)

The State Board of Elections dismissed Griffin's written protests challenging the ballots last month, which initiated a timeline in which the board would issue a certificate confirming Riggs' election this Friday. However, Tuesday's order stops such certification and tells Griffin and the board to file legal briefs with the justices over the next two weeks.

Riggs' democratic allies have accused Griffin and the state GOP of attempting to invalidate legitimate election outcomes.

According to Democratic Party Chair Anderson Clayton, Riggs "deserves her certificate of election and we are only in this position due to Jefferson Griffin refusing to accept the will of the people," as stated in a news release.

The election board that rejected Griffin's complaints consists of three Democrats and two Republicans.

In recent years, the Supreme Court in the ninth-largest state has been a focal point for partisan disputes in legal battles over redistricting, voter identification, and other voting rights.

The Associated Press contributed to this report.

by Danielle Wallace

politics

Biden Ducks Questions After Years of Trump's Unscripted Media Blitz

Biden Ducks Questions After Years of Trump's Unscripted Media Blitz

politics
Republicans in the Senate initiate campaign to prohibit Chinese citizens from acquiring property in the United States.

Republicans in the Senate initiate campaign to prohibit Chinese citizens from acquiring property in the United States.

politics
Johnson records Vance's maiden trip to the Oval Office on camera.

Johnson records Vance's maiden trip to the Oval Office on camera.

politics
Republicans plan to make Trump's executive orders permanent by working together.

Republicans plan to make Trump's executive orders permanent by working together.

politics
Johnson condemns Biden's last-minute pardons as 'shocking' and 'disgusting'.

Johnson condemns Biden's last-minute pardons as 'shocking' and 'disgusting'.

politics
Trump's Justice Department reforms reshape Bureau of Prisons leadership.

Trump's Justice Department reforms reshape Bureau of Prisons leadership.

politics
Biden-era health policies, including efforts to expand ObamaCare, were reversed on Trump's Day One actions.

Biden-era health policies, including efforts to expand ObamaCare, were reversed on Trump's Day One actions.

politics
Trump DHS expands expedited deportation powers as operations intensify.

Trump DHS expands expedited deportation powers as operations intensify.

politics
Biden order allowing transgender troops revoked by Trump in effort to remove DEI from military.

Biden order allowing transgender troops revoked by Trump in effort to remove DEI from military.

politics
President Trump's reversal of Biden-era climate emissions standards is criticized by Newsom using the ongoing LA fires.

President Trump's reversal of Biden-era climate emissions standards is criticized by Newsom using the ongoing LA fires.

politics
Republican leaders remain divided on reconciliation debate following Trump meeting.

Republican leaders remain divided on reconciliation debate following Trump meeting.

politics
The DOGE subcommittee now includes a Democrat who aims for 'good government'.

The DOGE subcommittee now includes a Democrat who aims for 'good government'.

politics
Biden sent Trump a 'very nice' letter with an 'inspirational' message, the new president stated.

Biden sent Trump a 'very nice' letter with an 'inspirational' message, the new president stated.

politics
Bishop excoriated by Trump as 'Radical Left hard line Trump hater' after politically charged prayer service.

Bishop excoriated by Trump as 'Radical Left hard line Trump hater' after politically charged prayer service.

politics
Sen. Thune proposes waiting until the weekend to confirm Trump's picks after Dems postpone votes: "Easy enough"

Sen. Thune proposes waiting until the weekend to confirm Trump's picks after Dems postpone votes: "Easy enough"

politics