The DOJ special counsel argues against dismissing Hunter Biden's indictment.

Although special counsel does not dispute that Hunter Biden received an act of mercy, it does not mean that a grand jury's decision to charge him should be overturned.

The DOJ special counsel argues against dismissing Hunter Biden's indictment.
The DOJ special counsel argues against dismissing Hunter Biden's indictment.

The special counsel assigned to the case recommends that the grand jury indictment against President Biden's son be denied, while attorneys for Hunter Biden argue for its dismissal entirely.

Late Sunday evening, President Biden granted his son Hunter a pardon, sparing him from being sentenced in two separate court cases where he was found guilty of purchasing a gun illegally and failing to pay $1.4 million in taxes. The president claimed these convictions were politically motivated and a "miscarriage of justice."

On Monday, Special Counsel David Weiss of the U.S. Department of Justice filed a request with Judge Maryellen Noreika, who presided over the gun case, to deny the motion to dismiss Hunter's indictment.

Weiss stated in the filing that the Government does not dispute the defendant's receipt of an act of mercy. However, this does not imply that the grand jury's decision to charge him, based on a finding of probable cause, should be overturned because the defendant falsely claimed that the charges were due to some improper motive or selective prosecution.

Biden and Hunter in Nantucket
President Biden and son Hunter Biden step out of a bookstore while shopping in Nantucket, Massachusetts, on November 29, 2024. Biden on Sunday issued an official pardon for his son Hunter, who was facing sentencing for two criminal cases related to tax evasion and the purchase of a firearm.  (MANDEL NGAN/AFP via Getty Images)

The special counsel stated that no court has supported the defendant's baseless claims, and his request to dismiss the indictment lacks legal backing, before requesting that the dismissal be denied.

Abbe Lowell, Hunter's attorney from Winston & Strawn LLP in Washington, D.C., argued that most courts support a dismissal.

"The Special Counsel's admission that the majority of courts dismiss indictments in similar situations provides legal support to Mr. Biden's claim that dismissal is warranted."

Hunter Biden, son of President Joe Biden, follows his attorney Abbe Lowell as they depart the House Rayburn Office Building following a surprise appearance
Hunter Biden, son of President Biden, follows his attorney Abbe Lowell on Capitol Hill in Washington on January 10, 2024.  (REUTERS/Kevin Lamarque)

In June, a jury of his peers found Hunter Biden guilty in a gun case, concluding that he made false statements in the purchase of a gun and provided false information to a federally licensed gun dealer, while also being in possession of a gun as an unlawful user or addict of a controlled substance.

His 2021 memoir "Beautiful Things" detailed his history of drug abuse, including his addiction to crack cocaine, which led him to refer to himself as a "crack daddy" to drug dealers, and anecdotes about drug deals, such as a Washington, D.C., crack dealer nicknamed "Bicycles."

In September, Hunter pleaded guilty to three felony tax offenses and six misdemeanor tax offenses for failing to pay at least $1.4 million in taxes, just as jury selection was about to begin in Los Angeles federal court.

Planet Chronicle Digital’s Emma Colton contributed to this report.

by Greg Wehner

politics

Trump's drug czar nominee falls through, and an outgoing GOP congressman seeks the role.

Trump's drug czar nominee falls through, and an outgoing GOP congressman seeks the role.

politics
After the pardon of Hunter Biden, Democrats renew their efforts to restrict the president's clemency powers.

After the pardon of Hunter Biden, Democrats renew their efforts to restrict the president's clemency powers.

politics
Trump names nominees for Army secretary, trade adviser, hostage envoy, and NASA administrator.

Trump names nominees for Army secretary, trade adviser, hostage envoy, and NASA administrator.

politics
Pete Hegseth intensifies Pentagon lobbying with consecutive meetings on Capitol Hill.

Pete Hegseth intensifies Pentagon lobbying with consecutive meetings on Capitol Hill.

politics
In a landmark case, the Supreme Court considers the treatments for transgender youth.

In a landmark case, the Supreme Court considers the treatments for transgender youth.

politics
The GOP Senate majority leader reveals the legislative plan for the Trump administration's initial 30 days.

The GOP Senate majority leader reveals the legislative plan for the Trump administration's initial 30 days.

politics
If Hegseth fails as Trump's defense secretary, DeSantis could be a potential replacement.

If Hegseth fails as Trump's defense secretary, DeSantis could be a potential replacement.

politics
FBI background checks agreement signed by Trump transition team.

FBI background checks agreement signed by Trump transition team.

politics
President Biden is accused of trying to "redefine history" with his decision to pardon his son Hunter Biden.

President Biden is accused of trying to "redefine history" with his decision to pardon his son Hunter Biden.

politics
Fani Willis instructed to share all correspondence with Jack Smith's special counsel.

Fani Willis instructed to share all correspondence with Jack Smith's special counsel.

politics
Florida Sheriff Chad Chronister withdraws from consideration as Trump's nominee to head the DEA.

Florida Sheriff Chad Chronister withdraws from consideration as Trump's nominee to head the DEA.

politics