The Chinese government defends its decision to ban TikTok, citing it as a powerful tool.

The solicitor general informed the court that the PRC has a significant demand for data on American users.

The Chinese government defends its decision to ban TikTok, citing it as a powerful tool.
The Chinese government defends its decision to ban TikTok, citing it as a powerful tool.

In court on Friday, the Biden administration's lawyers emphasized that TikTok's Chinese ownership poses a significant threat to American users' national security.

Elizabeth Prelogar, the U.S. Solicitor General, highlighted potential dangers that China could exploit TikTok's app, such as manipulating its algorithm to favor specific content or compelling ByteDance to divulge extensive user data collected by TikTok on American citizens.

""ByteDance could be compelled by the PRC to provide any data it has on Americans, making it a powerful tool for the PRC," Prelogar stated."

She stated that TikTok's extensive data set could provide the PRC with a potent tool for harassment, recruitment, and espionage.

The oral arguments commenced at 10 a.m. and are currently being broadcast live.

During TikTok's oral arguments, the justices on the bench showed doubt about the company's main argument that the law infringes on free speech.

What is TikTok's speech in question? Justice Clarence Thomas posed this question in the opening moments of oral arguments, hinting at the court's uncertainty about whether the law constitutes a First Amendment violation.

Tiktok protest
Participants hold signs in support of TikTok outside the U.S. Capitol Building on March 13, 2024 in Washington, D.C., as lawmakers voted to pass a law that would require TikTok to divest from its Chinese parent company, ByteDance, within nine months. (Anna Moneymaker/Getty Images)

TikTok's lawyer, Noel Francisco, argued on Friday that the case against TikTok is a violation of free speech protections under the First Amendment, as TikTok claims to be a U.S.-based corporation.

The government must prove a compelling interest and narrowly tailor any law that restricts First Amendment protections, which TikTok claims the law fails to achieve.

The U.S. Court of Appeals for the District of Columbia Circuit upheld the divestiture law last month, even though it is a challenging legal test to satisfy in court. This means that justices could theoretically consider the case under strict scrutiny and still opt to uphold the law, despite the looming Jan. 19 ban.

The case currently being heard by the court is the first to focus on the ownership of a platform or app, rather than speech, as noted by Justice Sonia Sotomayor on Friday.

The liberal justice raised doubts about whether the court would classify TikTok's divestiture requirement as a data control matter rather than a free-speech issue, as TikTok's legal team has argued.

Acknowledging that weighing the case as a data control case would result in a lower level of scrutiny, Francisco agreed.

In oral arguments on Friday, Francisco argued that the U.S. government has no legitimate reason to prevent foreign propaganda and that the platform and its owners should be granted the highest level of free speech protection under the U.S. Constitution.

Francisco argued that TikTok should be granted First Amendment protections as it is a U.S.-incorporated subsidiary, according to him.

The lawyer representing TikTok was questioned about the Chinese government's influence on the app and ByteDance's control over the algorithm that displays specific content to users.

Francisco stated that although some parts of the recommendation engine are owned by the Chinese government, TikTok is still operating in the United States.

If justices do not intervene or ByteDance agrees to sell, TikTok will be banned from operating in the U.S. by January 19th. The focus of oral arguments is on the First Amendment protections that should be granted to TikTok and its foreign owner, ByteDance.

The Supreme Court has previously ruled that speech by foreign governments or individuals does not receive full First Amendment protections.

The Biden administration contends that the law targets the company's control of the app, which attorneys for the administration argue could pose "grave national security threats" to Americans rather than its content.

The administration's lawyers will argue that Congress did not impose any restrictions on speech, based on viewpoint or content, and therefore fails to meet the criteria for free speech violations under the First Amendment.

Donald Trump TikTok photo illustration
President-elect Donald Trump's X account seen displayed on a smartphone with a TikTok logo. (Photo by Avishek Das / SOPA Images/Sipa USA)

The decision of the court could significantly affect the approximately 170 million individuals who utilize the app.

Supreme Court building
The U.S. Supreme Court building is seen in Washington, D.C. (AP Photo/Mariam Zuhaib))

In December, the justices agreed to an expedited hearing and will have only nine days to make a ruling before the ban goes into effect on January 19.

by Breanne Deppisch

politics

Biden Ducks Questions After Years of Trump's Unscripted Media Blitz

Biden Ducks Questions After Years of Trump's Unscripted Media Blitz

politics
Republicans in the Senate initiate campaign to prohibit Chinese citizens from acquiring property in the United States.

Republicans in the Senate initiate campaign to prohibit Chinese citizens from acquiring property in the United States.

politics
Johnson records Vance's maiden trip to the Oval Office on camera.

Johnson records Vance's maiden trip to the Oval Office on camera.

politics
Republicans plan to make Trump's executive orders permanent by working together.

Republicans plan to make Trump's executive orders permanent by working together.

politics
Johnson condemns Biden's last-minute pardons as 'shocking' and 'disgusting'.

Johnson condemns Biden's last-minute pardons as 'shocking' and 'disgusting'.

politics
Trump's Justice Department reforms reshape Bureau of Prisons leadership.

Trump's Justice Department reforms reshape Bureau of Prisons leadership.

politics
Biden-era health policies, including efforts to expand ObamaCare, were reversed on Trump's Day One actions.

Biden-era health policies, including efforts to expand ObamaCare, were reversed on Trump's Day One actions.

politics
Trump DHS expands expedited deportation powers as operations intensify.

Trump DHS expands expedited deportation powers as operations intensify.

politics
Biden order allowing transgender troops revoked by Trump in effort to remove DEI from military.

Biden order allowing transgender troops revoked by Trump in effort to remove DEI from military.

politics
President Trump's reversal of Biden-era climate emissions standards is criticized by Newsom using the ongoing LA fires.

President Trump's reversal of Biden-era climate emissions standards is criticized by Newsom using the ongoing LA fires.

politics
Republican leaders remain divided on reconciliation debate following Trump meeting.

Republican leaders remain divided on reconciliation debate following Trump meeting.

politics
The DOGE subcommittee now includes a Democrat who aims for 'good government'.

The DOGE subcommittee now includes a Democrat who aims for 'good government'.

politics
Biden sent Trump a 'very nice' letter with an 'inspirational' message, the new president stated.

Biden sent Trump a 'very nice' letter with an 'inspirational' message, the new president stated.

politics
Bishop excoriated by Trump as 'Radical Left hard line Trump hater' after politically charged prayer service.

Bishop excoriated by Trump as 'Radical Left hard line Trump hater' after politically charged prayer service.

politics
Sen. Thune proposes waiting until the weekend to confirm Trump's picks after Dems postpone votes: "Easy enough"

Sen. Thune proposes waiting until the weekend to confirm Trump's picks after Dems postpone votes: "Easy enough"

politics