Federal judges' reversal of retirement decisions is slammed by McConnell as 'partisan politics'.

Potential ethics complaints were threatened against circuit court judges who may reverse their retirements by McConnel.

Federal judges' reversal of retirement decisions is slammed by McConnell as 'partisan politics'.
Federal judges' reversal of retirement decisions is slammed by McConnell as 'partisan politics'.

On Monday, the Senate GOP leader criticized the decisions of two federal judges who changed their minds about retiring after the re-election of former President Trump in November.

Mitch McConnell, the Republican minority leader from Kentucky, criticized two "partisan Democrat district judges" who announced plans to "unretire" after the "American people voted to fire Democrats last month."

According to McConnell, only two judges have ever unretired after a presidential election, both Democrats, in 2004 and 2009. However, in just a matter of weeks, Democrats have already surpassed this all-time record. This raises concerns about open partisanship.

In November, Judge Algenon Marbley of Ohio informed President Biden that he intended to remain on the bench despite Biden's failure to nominate a replacement for him.

Sen. Mitch McConnell
Senate Minority Leader Mitch McConnell, R-Ky., takes a question from a reporter during a news conference following the weekly Senate Republican policy luncheon at the U.S. Capitol on Nov. 19, 2024 in Washington, D.C. (Andrew Harnik/Getty Images)

Since a successor had not been confirmed, Marbley, who was appointed by President Clinton, opted to remain on active status and fulfill the office's duties and obligations.

North Carolina's U.S. District Judge Max Cogburn, appointed by President Obama, has withdrawn plans to retire, according to Reuters.

Before the election, both Marbley and Cogburn had declared their intention to take senior status, which would have enabled them to reduce their workload until the president appointed a successor.

McConnell stated that the judges' decisions to withdraw their retirements following Trump's victory were influenced by "a political finger on the scale." He advised the incoming Trump administration to investigate all possible recusal options for these judges.

U.S. District Judge Algenon Marbley
U.S. District Judge Algenon L. Marbley, the first Black Chief District Judge in the Southern District of Ohio's history.  (Courtney Hergesheimer/Columbus Dispatch/USA TODAY NETWORK)

Two sitting circuit court judges who have announced retirements and have vacancies currently pending before the senate were warned by him against making similar decisions to "unretire."

"No circuit judge has ever unretired after a presidential election. This is unprecedented, and creating such a precedent would go against a rare bipartisan agreement on how to handle these vacancies," McConnell stated.

Last month, a bipartisan agreement on judicial nominations was reached, allowing Trump to appoint four crucial appellate court judges after he takes office in January.

Schumer and McConnell
Democratic Majority Leader Chuck Schumer, D-N.Y., struck a deal with McConnell to confirm several Biden judicial nominees, leaving four circuit court vacancies for Trump to fill next year.  (AP/Getty)

Republicans agreed to allow Senate Majority Leader Chuck Schumer to vote on cloture on nine of Biden's district court judges before Thanksgiving and confirm them when they return after the holiday. In exchange, Democrats would pull four circuit court nominees who lack the votes to get confirmed, allowing Trump to fill those vacancies next year.

According to a Democratic source, only two of the circuit court vacancies are guaranteed, and the other two may choose not to accept senior judge status.

If any retiring judge reversed their decision to take senior status because Trump won, McConnell warned that "significant ethics complaints" would be filed promptly.

"If you engage in political games, you can expect political rewards. However, I hope the judges make the right decision and enjoy their well-deserved retirement, leaving politics to the political branches."

Planet Chronicle Digital's Julia Johnson and Kelly Phares contributed to this report.

by Chris Pandolfo

politics

The next Ohio senator, who identifies as a "fiscal conservative," intends to "minimize government intervention in people's lives."

The next Ohio senator, who identifies as a "fiscal conservative," intends to "minimize government intervention in people's lives."

politics
The Treasury Department recovers $31 million in erroneous payments made to deceased individuals by the government.

The Treasury Department recovers $31 million in erroneous payments made to deceased individuals by the government.

politics
Legal experts criticize Biden's last-minute constitutional change as "cynical and irrelevant."

Legal experts criticize Biden's last-minute constitutional change as "cynical and irrelevant."

politics
Michelle Obama celebrates her birthday with her husband, who avoids key public events.

Michelle Obama celebrates her birthday with her husband, who avoids key public events.

politics
A methane emissions fee is being challenged by 23 state attorneys general who have filed a lawsuit against the EPA.

A methane emissions fee is being challenged by 23 state attorneys general who have filed a lawsuit against the EPA.

politics
Trump plans to make changes at the State Department without Senate confirmation, according to a source.

Trump plans to make changes at the State Department without Senate confirmation, according to a source.

politics
Sources reveal that DOGE co-leader Ramaswamy is considering a 2026 run for governor in Ohio.

Sources reveal that DOGE co-leader Ramaswamy is considering a 2026 run for governor in Ohio.

politics
Biden's official Twitter account faces criticism for referencing a non-existent constitutional amendment.

Biden's official Twitter account faces criticism for referencing a non-existent constitutional amendment.

politics
If Laken Riley were DHS secretary, she would still be alive, according to freshman senator Mayorkas.

If Laken Riley were DHS secretary, she would still be alive, according to freshman senator Mayorkas.

politics
Gov. Sanders reveals strategy to enable parents to take legal action against Big Tech for contributing to adolescent mental health emergency.

Gov. Sanders reveals strategy to enable parents to take legal action against Big Tech for contributing to adolescent mental health emergency.

politics
The last indoor inauguration ceremony took place in 1985, during the presidency of Ronald Reagan.

The last indoor inauguration ceremony took place in 1985, during the presidency of Ronald Reagan.

politics
Trump may avoid inaugural crowd size controversy by moving the swearing-in indoors.

Trump may avoid inaugural crowd size controversy by moving the swearing-in indoors.

politics
Under Biden, DOJ has been politicized; Ted Cruz believes Pam Bondi will reverse it.

Under Biden, DOJ has been politicized; Ted Cruz believes Pam Bondi will reverse it.

politics
On 'day one,' Trump's DHS nominee Noem vows to abolish contentious migrant app.

On 'day one,' Trump's DHS nominee Noem vows to abolish contentious migrant app.

politics
SCOTUS TikTok ban receives mixed reactions from privacy groups, experts, and parents.

SCOTUS TikTok ban receives mixed reactions from privacy groups, experts, and parents.

politics
Activist Forcibly Removed from Blinken's Last Press Conference: "I'm Being Hurt!"

Activist Forcibly Removed from Blinken's Last Press Conference: "I'm Being Hurt!"

politics
Trump may take action on TikTok ban in 'not too distant future' after reviewing SCOTUS decision.

Trump may take action on TikTok ban in 'not too distant future' after reviewing SCOTUS decision.

politics
The governor's first major act saw the elimination of the DEI department in a Midwest state.

The governor's first major act saw the elimination of the DEI department in a Midwest state.

politics