A bipartisan group of Texas lawmakers have expressed "serious doubts" about the conviction of a killer and are calling for their execution to be halted.

The case against Robert Roberson was constructed on unreliable scientific proof, according to the petition.

A bipartisan group of Texas lawmakers have expressed "serious doubts" about the conviction of a killer and are calling for their execution to be halted.
A bipartisan group of Texas lawmakers have expressed "serious doubts" about the conviction of a killer and are calling for their execution to be halted.

A group of Texas lawmakers, both Democrats and Republicans, urged Governor Abbott and the Board of Pardons and Paroles to halt the execution of a man who was convicted of murdering his two-year-old daughter in 2002.

On Oct. 17, Robert Roberson will be put to death by lethal injection, as prosecutors allege that he killed his daughter, Nikki Curtis, by violently shaking her and causing fatal injuries.

A group of 84 lawmakers from the Texas House, along with medical experts, death penalty attorneys, a former detective on the case, and bestselling novelist John Grisham, have come together to argue that the case against a planned execution was built on faulty scientific evidence in a rare show of bipartisan support in the Lone Star State.

"According to Democrat Rep. Joe Moody, a majority of the Texas House, including members from both parties, have grave concerns about Robert Roberson's execution. Moody emphasized that this issue is about life and death and should not be influenced by political ideology."

Robert Roberson III
Robert Roberson III is scheduled to be executed by lethal injection Oct. 17. (Texas Department of Criminal Justice via AP)

The governor of Texas has the power to grant a 30-day reprieve from execution, but full clemency requires the recommendation of the majority of the Board of Pardons and Paroles, which is appointed by the governor.

In his five years in office, Governor Abbott has granted clemency in only one death row case, commuting Thomas Whitaker's death sentence to life in prison an hour before his scheduled execution in 2018. Whitaker had been convicted of arranging a plot that left his mother and brother fatally shot and his father wounded.

The petition of lawmakers claims that Roberson's conviction was based on faulty scientific evidence and highlights that experts have largely discredited the notion that Nikki's symptoms were indicative of shaken baby syndrome.

"Nikki's death was not a crime, but it may be considered a crime if a parent is unable to explain complex medical problems that even trained medical professionals failed to understand at the time," the petition states. "We know that Nikki's lungs were severely infected and straining for oxygen for days or even weeks before her collapse."

Texas Rep. Joe Moody
Texas Rep. Joe Moody, D-El Paso, speaks at a meeting of the House Investigative Committee, June 9, 2022, at the state Capitol in Austin, Texas. (AP)

In 2002, Roberson, who has always maintained his innocence, took his daughter to the hospital after discovering her unconscious with blue lips. Doctors at the time were skeptical of Roberson's claim that his daughter had fallen off the bed while sleeping, with some testifying at trial that her symptoms were consistent with the signs of shaken baby syndrome.

Medical professionals are increasingly cautioning against diagnosing shaken baby syndrome too quickly, as it can be influenced by a child's medical history.

Those from Stanford University Medical Center, the University of Pennsylvania, and Children's Minnesota Hospital are among the medical experts who signed the petition.

Roberson's lawyers argued that his behavior was misconstrued against him due to his autism, and that physicians neglected to consider other possible medical causes for the child's symptoms, such as pneumonia.

Greg Abbott
Texas Governor Greg Abbott makes an announcement on the future of the space industry in Texas, at NASA's Johnson Space Center in Houston, Texas, on March 26, 2024. ((Photo by SUZANNE CORDEIRO/AFP via Getty Images))

In 2016, the Texas Court of Criminal Appeals put a hold on Roberson's execution. Nevertheless, the court resumed the case in 2020 and set a new date for his execution.

The defense argued that the science of shaken baby syndrome has changed, but prosecutors maintain that the evidence against Roberson remains sound.

A former chief of detectives in Palestine, Texas, who assisted in Roberson's prosecution, publicly endorsed the petition and called for the state to halt the execution.

Wharton stated that he is convinced of Robert's innocence after gaining all the necessary knowledge.

The Associated Press contributed to this report.

by Landon Mion

politics

Biden Ducks Questions After Years of Trump's Unscripted Media Blitz

Biden Ducks Questions After Years of Trump's Unscripted Media Blitz

politics
Republicans in the Senate initiate campaign to prohibit Chinese citizens from acquiring property in the United States.

Republicans in the Senate initiate campaign to prohibit Chinese citizens from acquiring property in the United States.

politics
Johnson records Vance's maiden trip to the Oval Office on camera.

Johnson records Vance's maiden trip to the Oval Office on camera.

politics
Republicans plan to make Trump's executive orders permanent by working together.

Republicans plan to make Trump's executive orders permanent by working together.

politics
Johnson condemns Biden's last-minute pardons as 'shocking' and 'disgusting'.

Johnson condemns Biden's last-minute pardons as 'shocking' and 'disgusting'.

politics
Trump's Justice Department reforms reshape Bureau of Prisons leadership.

Trump's Justice Department reforms reshape Bureau of Prisons leadership.

politics
Biden-era health policies, including efforts to expand ObamaCare, were reversed on Trump's Day One actions.

Biden-era health policies, including efforts to expand ObamaCare, were reversed on Trump's Day One actions.

politics
Trump DHS expands expedited deportation powers as operations intensify.

Trump DHS expands expedited deportation powers as operations intensify.

politics
Biden order allowing transgender troops revoked by Trump in effort to remove DEI from military.

Biden order allowing transgender troops revoked by Trump in effort to remove DEI from military.

politics
President Trump's reversal of Biden-era climate emissions standards is criticized by Newsom using the ongoing LA fires.

President Trump's reversal of Biden-era climate emissions standards is criticized by Newsom using the ongoing LA fires.

politics
Republican leaders remain divided on reconciliation debate following Trump meeting.

Republican leaders remain divided on reconciliation debate following Trump meeting.

politics
The DOGE subcommittee now includes a Democrat who aims for 'good government'.

The DOGE subcommittee now includes a Democrat who aims for 'good government'.

politics
Biden sent Trump a 'very nice' letter with an 'inspirational' message, the new president stated.

Biden sent Trump a 'very nice' letter with an 'inspirational' message, the new president stated.

politics
Bishop excoriated by Trump as 'Radical Left hard line Trump hater' after politically charged prayer service.

Bishop excoriated by Trump as 'Radical Left hard line Trump hater' after politically charged prayer service.

politics
Sen. Thune proposes waiting until the weekend to confirm Trump's picks after Dems postpone votes: "Easy enough"

Sen. Thune proposes waiting until the weekend to confirm Trump's picks after Dems postpone votes: "Easy enough"

politics