What are the issues with South Korean presidents facing ignominy, impeachment, death sentences, and imprisonment?

After issuing a bizarre martial law order, President faces disgrace alongside Korea's former leaders.

What are the issues with South Korean presidents facing ignominy, impeachment, death sentences, and imprisonment?
What are the issues with South Korean presidents facing ignominy, impeachment, death sentences, and imprisonment?

On Saturday, South Korean President Yoon Suk Yeol was not impeached after his People Power Party (PPP) boycotted the vote. However, Yoon's troubles are far from over. The leader of his own party, the PPP, called for Yoon's presidential powers to be suspended after it was revealed that the president had ordered the arrests of his political opponents following the announcement of martial law. Among those on the list was the head of the PPP.

Despite the possibility of another impeachment vote, Yoon has already tarnished his reputation with an unconstitutional power grab. Whether he completes his term or is removed from office, he will join the ranks of predecessors with questionable legacies.

South Korean President Yoon Suk Yeol
People watch a TV screen showing South Korean President Yoon Suk Yeol's televised briefing at a bus terminal in Seoul, South Korea, Tuesday, Dec. 3, 2024. (AP Photo/Ahn Young-joon)

If Yoon were to enter a prison cell, it would not be surprising in Korea, as the probability of him doing so is low. Out of the last six democratically elected presidents of Korea, only one has not served time in jail. This amounts to a success rate of approximately 17%.

Despite its picture-perfect image, Korean democracy has a dark past. Since World War II, the country has had 13 heads of state, and not all of them were champions of democracy. One was forced to resign and flee, two were overthrown in military coups, and one was murdered by his closest friend, who was also the head of South Korea's intelligence agency.

All eight democratically elected presidents, including Yoon, have been involved in scandals. Even Kim Dae-jung, who won a Nobel Peace Prize and was a dissident-turned-president, is now viewed less positively due to revelations that he bribed North Korea to hold an unprecedented inter-Korean summit meeting.

Jailed former president Roh Tae-Woo (R) looks on as South Korean new President Kim Dae-Jung (L) shakes hands with jailed former president Chun Doo-Hwan (not in picture)  before taking the oath as President during the ceremony of the Inauguration at the National Assembly in Seoul 25 February.
Jailed former president Roh Tae-Woo (R) looks on as South Korean new President Kim Dae-Jung (L) shakes hands with jailed former president Chun Doo-Hwan (not in picture)  before taking the oath as President during the ceremony of the Inauguration at the National Assembly in Seoul 25 February.       (Photo by Choo Youn-Kong/AFP via Getty Images)

Four Korean presidents have served time in prison, with two being impeached and one convicted and removed from office. One ex-president took his own life by jumping off a 150-foot-high mountain cliff in 2009 after his aides, relatives, and even wife and son were investigated for bribery and other corruption charges. Since the country's founding, two presidents have been sentenced to death but later pardoned.

It is surprising that despite being a democratic, highly educated, technologically advanced, conservative, and deeply religious society, Korea's ex-presidents rarely experience a happy post-presidency.

Former South Korean president Lee Myung-bak (L) arrives at a court to attend his trial in Seoul on September 6, 2018. Prosecutors demanded 20 years in prison for former South Korean president Lee Myung-bak for corruption,  the last of the country's four living ex-leaders to be embroiled in a criminal inquiry. J
Former South Korean president Lee Myung-bak (L) arrives at a court to attend his trial in Seoul on September 6, 2018. Prosecutors demanded 20 years in prison for former South Korean president Lee Myung-bak for corruption,  the last of the country's four living ex-leaders to be embroiled in a criminal inquiry. J (Ung Yeon-Je/AFP via Getty Images)

"Professor Lee stated to Planet Chronicle Digital that the president of Korea possesses a significant amount of power, which he believes is excessive. This has led some to label it an "imperial presidency," which ultimately results in hubris."

TOPSHOT - South Korean ousted leader Park Geun-Hye (L) arrives at the Seoul Central District Court in Seoul on May 25, 2017, for her trial over the massive corruption scandal that led to her downfall.
TOPSHOT - South Korean ousted leader Park Geun-Hye (L) arrives at the Seoul Central District Court in Seoul on May 25, 2017, for her trial over the massive corruption scandal that led to her downfall.   (Photo by Jung Yeon-Je/Pool/AFP via Getty Images)

In North Korea, people show their devotion to the idea of a communist state with a dynastic leader, Kim Jong-un, who is adored and followed by an entourage of scribes who record every word he says for posterity.

In South Korea, strict discipline and grueling work hours have led to the creation of globally respected brands such as Samsung and Hyundai, as well as the dominance of K-pop and K-drama in Asia and around the world.

The dark side of South Korea's culture includes the overzealousness that is prevalent in North Korea. South Korean bosses, teachers, elders, and leaders are used to being obeyed. At the top of the social hierarchy sits the president, who lives in a bubble where questioning their judgment is almost taboo. These leaders often develop a strong tendency to see themselves as infallible, if not above the law. President Yoon, like many before him, is discovering too late that there are red lines, and the Rubicon now lies behind him.

by Eryk Michael Smith

world

Russia and Iran are set to finalize their partnership agreement just before Trump's inauguration.

Russia and Iran are set to finalize their partnership agreement just before Trump's inauguration.

world
Trump's inauguration: Brazilian court rejects Bolsonaro's travel request.

Trump's inauguration: Brazilian court rejects Bolsonaro's travel request.

world
During a visit to Kyiv, UK leader Starmer finalizes a "100-year partnership" agreement with Ukraine.

During a visit to Kyiv, UK leader Starmer finalizes a "100-year partnership" agreement with Ukraine.

world
An American college rape suspect is being extradited to the US.

An American college rape suspect is being extradited to the US.

world
Vatican confirms 2nd fall in matter of weeks, leaving Pope Francis injured.

Vatican confirms 2nd fall in matter of weeks, leaving Pope Francis injured.

world
Reports suggest that the Israel-Hamas deal to free Americans in Gaza may be delayed.

Reports suggest that the Israel-Hamas deal to free Americans in Gaza may be delayed.

world
Hamas is accused by Israel's Netanyahu of attempting to withdraw from the cease-fire agreement.

Hamas is accused by Israel's Netanyahu of attempting to withdraw from the cease-fire agreement.

world
Israel-Hamas cease-fire deal hailed as 'long-awaited news' by world leaders, US politicians.

Israel-Hamas cease-fire deal hailed as 'long-awaited news' by world leaders, US politicians.

world
Mozambique's disputed election results in Chapo's inauguration as president.

Mozambique's disputed election results in Chapo's inauguration as president.

world
After cease-fire deal, Israeli hostage families express guarded hope for safe return of loved ones.

After cease-fire deal, Israeli hostage families express guarded hope for safe return of loved ones.

world
Iran's president rejects allegation that Iran attempted to assassinate Trump.

Iran's president rejects allegation that Iran attempted to assassinate Trump.

world
Amid criticisms, US lacks a 'clear strategy' to address record gang violence in Haiti.

Amid criticisms, US lacks a 'clear strategy' to address record gang violence in Haiti.

world
Trump requested to intervene in Puerto Rico after Maduro threatened to invade the US territory.

Trump requested to intervene in Puerto Rico after Maduro threatened to invade the US territory.

world
Weeks after martial law chaos, the impeached South Korean president is being held in detention.

Weeks after martial law chaos, the impeached South Korean president is being held in detention.

world
An agreement has been reached for the release of hostages in the context of the Israel-Hamas cease-fire.

An agreement has been reached for the release of hostages in the context of the Israel-Hamas cease-fire.

world
Investigators in South Korea attempt to detain the impeached president for a second time.

Investigators in South Korea attempt to detain the impeached president for a second time.

world
Hundreds of people, including survivors and the deceased, were rescued from an abandoned South African mine, while dozens more remain trapped underground.

Hundreds of people, including survivors and the deceased, were rescued from an abandoned South African mine, while dozens more remain trapped underground.

world
Trump's new ambassador to Ukraine issues warning to Iran, urging 'maximum pressure must be reinstated'

Trump's new ambassador to Ukraine issues warning to Iran, urging 'maximum pressure must be reinstated'

world