According to experts, Netanyahu's refusal to comply with Biden-Harris's threats regarding the Rafah invasion resulted in the elimination of Sinwar.

Hamas executed 6 hostages, including American-Israeli Hersh Goldberg-Polin, just a short distance from where Sinwar was eliminated.

According to experts, Netanyahu's refusal to comply with Biden-Harris's threats regarding the Rafah invasion resulted in the elimination of Sinwar.
According to experts, Netanyahu's refusal to comply with Biden-Harris's threats regarding the Rafah invasion resulted in the elimination of Sinwar.

According to military and Middle East experts, Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu's decision to ignore warnings from President Biden and Vice President Harris not to conquer the last major stronghold of Hamas terrorists in Rafah was correct.

On Wednesday, the Israel Defense Forces (IDF) and the Shin Bet intelligence agency declared that "soldiers from the Southern Command killed Yahya Sinwar, the leader of the Hamas terrorist organization, during an operation in the southern Gaza Strip."

Earlier this year, Biden and Harris warned Israel about going into Rafah, where Sinwar met his end, but later congratulated Israel over the death of the Hamas terror chief.

IDF forces in Rafah
IDF forces operating in Rafah, a city in the Gaza Strip. (IDF Spokesman's Office)

Nearly 1,200 people were massacred on Oct. 7, 2023, including over 40 American citizens, under the supervision of Sinwar.

In March, Harris refused to rule out "consequences" for Israel if it proceeded with an invasion of Rafah in Gaza.

""I have studied the maps and I can confirm that there's nowhere for those folks to go," Harris told ABC News at the time."

In March, Jake Sullivan, Biden's National Security Advisor, also expressed concern, mirroring Harris' warning.

"During a White House Press briefing, Sullivan stated that Hamas should not be permitted a safe haven in Rafah or any other location. However, a significant military operation in Gaza would be a grave error. It would result in more innocent civilian casualties, exacerbate the already severe humanitarian crisis, intensify the chaos in Gaza, and further isolate Israel internationally."

Biden Netanyahu
President Biden meets with Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu in the Oval Office at the White House July 25, 2024, in Washington, D.C. (Andrew Harnik/Getty Images)

In May, Biden threatened Israel by stating that he would not provide the Jewish state with weapons if it entered Rafah. Biden told CNN that if Israel entered Rafah, he would not supply the weapons that have been used historically to deal with the city.

According to Amit Segal, chief political analyst of Israel's Channel 12, the elimination of Sinwar demonstrates that the continuation of the war was not arbitrary, the entry into Rafah was not motivated by revenge, and the refusal to surrender to Hamas to resolve the northern front was not hasty.

"To guarantee that the entire Middle East witnesses the consequences of attacking Israel, a strategy exists."

Hamas leader Sinwar.
Yahya Sinwar, center, the late leader of Hamas, during a ceremony for members killed by Israeli air strikes at Yarmouk Stadium May 24, 2021, in Gaza City, Gaza.   (Laurent Van der Stockt/Getty Images)

An IDF spokesman stated that Sinwar's primary objective was to erase Israel from existence. The operation's success is just one piece of a year-long effort in Gaza.

In August, six hostages were executed in the same tunnel where Sinwar was located.

One of the six hostages murdered was Israeli-American Hersh Goldberg-Polin.

"The IDF spokesman stated that Sinwar was located near the tunnel, and there were signs of senior Hamas leaders in the Rafah area."

The IDF spokesman stated that there are 14,000 Hamas booby-trapped buildings in the Rafah area.

Gaza Strip Rafah
Israel's Prime Minister, Benjamin Netanyahu, points at a map of the Gaza Strip during a press conference at the Government Press Office in Jerusalem Sept. 4, 2024.  (Abir Sultan/Pool/AFP via Getty Images)

If Prime Minister Netanyahu had heeded Biden and Harris' advice and avoided entering Rafah, we might never have reached Sinwar. The majority of Americans and Israelis supported our entry into Rafah and desire to see Hamas eradicated from history. Now it's time to put an end to Hamas and bring back the hostages, as Israeli Lt. Col (res) Yoni Chetboun, a former Knesset deputy speaker and decorated special forces operator, stated on Planet Chronicle Digital.

The misjudgment of Harris about the ground war in Gaza led to criticism and ridicule on social media from foreign policy experts. Caroline Glick, an American-Israeli Middle East expert, wrote on X that Sinwar was killed in Rafah, a mile from the Egyptian border. Kamala threatened Israel with sanctions if they went in, and she studied the maps.

Despite the efforts of the U.S. government and the European Union to persuade Israel to abandon its plans to eliminate Hamas and Hezbollah, Netanyahu remains unwavering in his pursuit of war.

In February, Josep Borrell, the European Union's foreign policy chief, stated that there was no military solution to defeat Hamas, despite suggesting that the United States reduce military aid to Israel.

Protests calling for cease-fire in Israel
Protesters rally outside the Defense Ministry against the government and to show support for the hostages kidnapped during the deadly Oct. 7 attack amid the ongoing conflict in Gaza between Israel and Hamas in Tel Aviv, Israel, Sept. 1, 2024. (Reuters/Florion Goga)

According to Max Abrahms, a renowned expert on counterterrorism and a professor of political science at Northeastern University, Biden and Harris have been advising Netanyahu based on American political calculations. The White House is aware of the strong anti-Israel sentiment within the Democratic Party and has attempted to pressure Netanyahu to withdraw Israeli forces from Gaza before the Hamas threat is fully addressed, particularly in opposition to a Rafah operation.

"If Netanyahu had followed that advice, Sinwar would still be alive. It is crucial for Netanyahu to ignore this White House's advice as he considers military options against Iran."

During a State Department briefing on Thursday, a reporter asked Spokesman Matthew Miller if the Biden Administration's policy on Israel invading Rafah was preemptive in light of the recent news of Sinwar's death.

Miller stated that they had always made it clear that they supported Israel's counterterrorism operations against Hamas leaders and militants, and that they provided active intelligence support for those operations.

No response was received from President Biden and Vice President Kamala Harris regarding their warnings to Netanyahu about Rafah.

Planet Chronicle Digital’s Anders Hagstrom contributed to this report.

by Benjamin Weinthal

world

An Africa-based Task Force has been established to address concerns about terrorism from Iran and jihadi organizations.

An Africa-based Task Force has been established to address concerns about terrorism from Iran and jihadi organizations.

world
Putin and Xi pledge to strengthen their alliance following Trump's return to the White House.

Putin and Xi pledge to strengthen their alliance following Trump's return to the White House.

world
Trump administration praised by mother of missing Marine veteran as search for son continues.

Trump administration praised by mother of missing Marine veteran as search for son continues.

world
Trump's Threat to Retake the Panama Canal Sparks Russia's Protest

Trump's Threat to Retake the Panama Canal Sparks Russia's Protest

world
Israeli military chief resigns due to October 7 Hamas massacre: 'A constant burden'

Israeli military chief resigns due to October 7 Hamas massacre: 'A constant burden'

world
Trump's return to the White House prompts reaction from world leaders.

Trump's return to the White House prompts reaction from world leaders.

world
A fire at a popular ski hotel in Turkey results in the death of 66 individuals.

A fire at a popular ski hotel in Turkey results in the death of 66 individuals.

world
What were the contents of the brown bags given to Israeli hostages freed by Hamas?

What were the contents of the brown bags given to Israeli hostages freed by Hamas?

world
A major counterterrorism operation is underway in a West Bank city by the Israeli military.

A major counterterrorism operation is underway in a West Bank city by the Israeli military.

world
On Inauguration Day, Israeli president praises Trump's work to release hostages, calling him a 'true friend'.

On Inauguration Day, Israeli president praises Trump's work to release hostages, calling him a 'true friend'.

world
As part of a cease-fire agreement, Israel frees 90 Palestinian prisoners to secure the release of hostages.

As part of a cease-fire agreement, Israel frees 90 Palestinian prisoners to secure the release of hostages.

world
A cease-fire agreement between Israel and Hamas may allow the rearming of terrorists in Gaza.

A cease-fire agreement between Israel and Hamas may allow the rearming of terrorists in Gaza.

world
Israelis rejoice as first hostages are released after 471 days in captivity.

Israelis rejoice as first hostages are released after 471 days in captivity.

world
A report states that the German ambassador has warned that Trump's 'maximum disruption' agenda will 'undermine' democratic principles.

A report states that the German ambassador has warned that Trump's 'maximum disruption' agenda will 'undermine' democratic principles.

world
The Israel-Hamas cease-fire will be implemented on Sunday, and its implications will be closely monitored.

The Israel-Hamas cease-fire will be implemented on Sunday, and its implications will be closely monitored.

world
In Tehran, two Supreme Court judges were fatally shot by a gunman, according to state media reports. Afterward, the assailant took his own life.

In Tehran, two Supreme Court judges were fatally shot by a gunman, according to state media reports. Afterward, the assailant took his own life.

world
Qatar announces cease-fire between Israel and Hamas to begin Sunday morning.

Qatar announces cease-fire between Israel and Hamas to begin Sunday morning.

world